High Court rules ‘predatory’ Wigan A&E doctor should have been barred

A High Court judge has ruled that a doctor who used colleagues' medical conditions for his own gratification should have been barred from the medical register, citing a lack of insight and public confidence in the medical profession.

A ‘predatory’ doctor who used colleagues’ medical conditions for his own ‘gratification’ should have been barred from the profession, a High Court judge has ruled.

A panel ruled that Dr Khush Bakhat Muhammad Zeeshan conducted ‘sexually motivated examinations’ on colleagues at Wigan A&Eplaceholder image
A panel ruled that Dr Khush Bakhat Muhammad Zeeshan conducted ‘sexually motivated examinations’ on colleagues at Wigan A&E | MA

Dr Khush Bakhat Muhammad Zeeshan received a 12-month suspension in March after a tribunal found he had conducted ‘sexually motivated examinations’ on two junior colleagues. His conduct was slammed at the time as ‘predatory’ and ‘opportunistic’ by the Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service.

The incidents occurred at the A&E department of the Royal Albert Edward Infirmary, in Wigan, after the women spoke of their health concerns in front of him. But Zeeshan sexually touched the women, including on the breasts and bottom, during the treatments, the tribunal heard.

Zeeshan was judged to have ‘exploited the health concerns of two female junior colleagues’, with the panel ruling this ‘serious misconduct’.

Despite this, the tribunal felt testimonials from colleagues, actions taken by Zeeshan around consent, and a lack of further incidents in the five years since his actions were reported acted as mitigation in his defence. It also felt Zeeshan’s denial of the allegations against him meant he had not been able to ‘demonstrate significant insight’ into his misconduct so panel members could not ‘fully assess’ the risk of repetition.

The tribunal ruled he should be suspended for a 12-month period to ‘allow him an opportunity to show that he had developed insight into the concerns identified, and that he had taken steps to remediate his misconduct’. Zeeshan’s licence would be reviewed towards the end of that period, with him required to demonstrate the steps he had taken towards this, the tribunal said. If he did not, the reviewing tribunal would then be able to opt to erase him from the medical register.

Following an appeal from the General Medical Council (GMC), High Court judge Mr Justice Squires has now ruled the tribunal’s decision to be ‘wrong’, saying Zeeshan should have been erased from the medical register.

The tribunal’s decision ‘departed’ from guidance around sexual misconduct, the court report states. That guidance advises any sanction short of erasure will ‘generally be inappropriate’ when sexual misconduct is found to be sexually motivated, as it was in this case.

The report acknowledges this is a ‘steer’ but said the tribunal failed to satisfactorily explain why it had departed from it. Mr Justice Squire added there was, in his view, ‘no good or sufficient reason upon which a properly directed tribunal could reasonably decide not to follow the steer’ in this case.

Regarding Zeeshan’s actions, Mr Justice Squires said it was ‘very difficult to see anything in the surrounding context that would mitigate it or render it less serious than it at first appears’, adding ‘nothing of that kind’ was identified by the tribunal.

In examining the facts of the case, Mr Justice Squires went on to rule these incidents ‘have the capacity to significantly undermine public confidence in the medical profession’.

He added: “Patients will often see doctors in situations of acute vulnerability, and they need to be able to trust implicitly that if a doctor asks them to remove clothing or touches them intimately, that is being done solely because it is clinically necessary, and not in any way for the doctor’s personal sexual gratification.

“Such trust is obviously undermined by a doctor acting in the way in which the respondent did. That was compounded by the respondent exploiting the health concerns of junior colleagues to persuade them to be alone with him and to submit to intimate touching under the guise of treatment.

“That was, as the [tribunal] found, “predatory” behaviour, and it is of particular concern that it happened twice in such a short period.”

Positive testimonials about a doctor’s work from colleagues were ‘of limited, if any relevance’ in sexual misconduct cases, he continued. This was instead a question of public confidence, with Mr Justice Squires saying it would ‘not promote public confidence in the medical profession to learn that someone who had abused their position as a doctor to commit serious sexual misconduct had been allowed to continue to practice as they were otherwise a good clinician’.

Similarly, he dismissed the tribunal’s acceptance of a lack of subsequent incidents as a justifiable reason to depart from the guidance.

The report states: “The Respondent committed the second incident less than a month after the first. He was then reported to the Trust on the day of the second incident, and has, since then, been under investigation culminating in the [tribunal] decision followed by the present appeal.

“It would clearly be of even greater concern if he had committed further similar sexual misconduct while under investigation for the earlier incidents, but the fact that he has not repeated the misconduct while under active investigation cannot be sufficient to avoid erasure.”

On the matter of insight, the judge added: “It cannot be sufficient to promote and maintain public confidence in the medical profession, and promote and maintain professional standards, if a doctor guilty of sexual misconduct, which should ordinarily lead to erasure due to its “inherent seriousness”, avoids the sanction because they may develop further insight into their conduct in the future.”

Zeeshan had denied the allegations against him. However, the original tribunal found the accounts presented by the two women to be more believable.

The first, named just as Ms B in the report, had complained of back pain, with Zeeshan then offering to ‘manipulate’ her back. The tribunal found, ‘on the balance of probabilities, he went on to straddle her, and to touch her on the bottom and under her clothes.

A medical expert told the panel there was no reason for Zeeshan to do these things as part of ‘any standard musculoskeletal spinal manipulation technique’.

The second woman, Ms A, was speaking to other colleagues about a swollen lymph node in her groin. Zeeshan then offered to check her armpits for lumps. Ms A said he told her she had a ‘higher risk of breast cancer’ as a woman, and she accepted the exam because he was a ‘trusted medical professional’.

The panel found, ‘on the balance of probabilities’, Zeeshan went on to examine her breasts to which Ms A said she had not expected or consented. While a medical expert said the breast exam was part of a ‘competent’ procedure of this type, he added it was not ‘reasonable’ to do this without ‘explicit consent’.

A GMC spokesperson said: “We welcome the High Court’s decision. There is no place for any form of sexual assault, harassment or misconduct in the medical profession.

“We had argued for Dr Zeeshan to be removed from the medical register, because of the seriousness of his actions, and lack of insight. We will always take action where we believe a sanction may not protect patients or uphold confidence in the profession.”

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1853
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice