The impact of the immigration debate on the Makerfield by-election
The immigration debate is dividing the community as people prepare to head to the polls later this month.
Driving down Walthew Lane towards the heart of Platt Bridge, many people were braving the weather on a wet afternoon to tuck into a classic lunch for a Wiganer – a Galloway’s pie.


The women behind the counter said the Makerfield by-election was a topic hotter than the baked goods they were dishing out.
They’ve even been visited by politicians in recent days – none of whom have fared well with customers apparently.


But one phrase uttered at the bakery in recent weeks – almost as much as "pie, please” – has been “immigration”.
A spat on social media platform X between Nigel Farage and Andy Burnham has showcased how central the topic of immigration is in the build-up to the by-election on June 18.
The Reform UK leader shared a post depicting migrants crossing the English Channel holding "Vote Andy” signs.
In the post Mr Farage wrote: “Andy Burnham is for them, not for you. Vote Reform in Makerfield’.”


The Labour candidate for Makerfield and mayor of Greater Manchester replied: “Getting desperate, lad?”. Then he followed with: “maybe keep the crypto millions for something else”.
When shown a screenshot of this exchange, Platt Wazzers (people from Platt Bridge) were sparked into life when it came to politics and, in particular, immigration.
“Well that’s just typical”, “I’m not a fan of Reform” or “don’t even go there” were just some of the reactions to the spat on X. One woman simply said “yeah, get rid of them” and walked off.
The most telling sign that immigration was a hot topic was the sheer amount of tales people had in their minds about crimes committed by illegal immigrants – all gruesome, violent and horrific incidents.
But they were vague in detail, unsubstantiated and almost always heard through social media or via word of mouth.
“I think we’re overrun with them,” one woman said. “I’m on minimum wage and the stuff they have is ridiculous. They’re on more money than I’m on a month.
“If they come across, work and pay their taxes, fair enough. But they’re not, they’re claiming all these benefits.
“The cost of living is awful for us. This is dividing communities and it’s overboard.”
Her friend added: “We’re seeing longer waits for the doctors. This issue is what is causing the divide in the area.
“People don’t want to go out as much. Women don’t seem to want to go out on their own. Me and her will go out together.
“People are following kids home. You just don’t know what is going on anymore.”
The pair, like many with similar views in Platt Bridge, were not keen to share their identity.
Once again they described stories they’ve heard through social media of illegal immigrants targeting women and children – but can’t point to specific cases.
A lot of these scaremongering stories are changing the dynamic of the community, no matter what side of the immigration debate people sit on.
Martin Harrison, who has lived in the area for 52 years, said: “I’ll get the bus on a Thursday night, but there is only me that is white on it. I’ve nothing against them, but there are more people that don’t speak English.
“A lot of people say the same thing as well. Platt Bridge is more diverse than people would think.
“I live on Halford Street, they built some flats and stuff. They’ve built more and more houses now.
“But my neighbours said ‘who’s that’, because there are so many people coming in that we don’t know. There are people down the street that are Polish and Romanian and we get on well with them, yet some of the others at the bottom ignore them.
“I think the community is falling apart. You used to be able to keep your window open at night, but now people lock everything up.
“I don’t have an issue with immigration. But you see families of four or five children, but imagine if they stick around for another 10 years and have the same amount of kids. We’re going to be overrun by people who are not Platt Wazzers.”
Martin was fine with legal immigration, but he also spoke of unsubstantiated dark stories he had heard of illegal immigrants committing crimes.
Kathleen Smith has lots of friends who have come to the country legally. She says they’ve been targeted with racist abuse by her neighbours when they come to visit.
“Most of my mates are foreign, but they’re here legally,” the 42-year-old said. “It’s the people coming on the boats that are causing the problem.
“I am scared because I’m the mother of a 15-year-old. I’m worried about her and my granddaughter.
“I have had problems with people near me over this. There is trouble in the community because of immigration.
“The neighbours aren’t like what they used to be, we’ve lost our community.
“My friends from abroad work and pay their taxes. They get the backlash from the immigration issues. They won’t come to mine any more because people in my street shout racist abuse at them and they’re scared. It’s just ignorance.”
Kathleen was horrified by the racism she had witnessed. But, again, she was describing incidents of crimes committed by illegal immigrants that she had seen via social media.
How many of these incidents that actually happened is hard to quantify, but it is clear that stories of this ilk are creating fear in the area and leading to less people going out at night or alone.
The LDRS spoke to two women who came to England as legal immigrants. Neither wanted to be fully identified to avoid any undue attention, but admitted they had not been targeted whilst living in Platt Bridge.
Mercy Ndidi, who moved to the area recently, saw a screenshot of the social media post shared by Nigel Farage and simply said: “UK politics is strange”.
Ky Yuen came to England from Hong Kong two years ago. She believes immigration for legal immigrants has become a problem also, describing how a number of people she knows have had problems renewing their visas, with tight controls on how much people need to earn to stay in the country.
The 41-year-old said: “When the Labour Party changed the immigration policy, some of my friends struggled because the conditions were different to when they arrived. I don’t think it’s fair.
“To be honest I don’t like videos and pictures like this. I think it’s very dangerous because they say all this but don’t have a solution.
“The slogan, I don’t think it’s good. I think it does create fear because less people want to go out and speak to other people in the community now.”
Immigration has never been too far from the political headlines in recent years and has become more prevalent since Brexit.
It is going to be a key issue for people in Makerfield as we head towards polling day on June 18.
It has been confirmed that 14 candidates from 11 parties and three independents will contest the by-election.
The candidates are: Jake Austin (Liberal Democrats), Count Binface (Count Binface Party), Andy Burnham (Labour and Co-operative Party), Dan Clarke (Libertarian Party), John Dyer (independent), Ed Gemmell (Climate Party), Paul Gould (independent), Howling Laud Hope (Official Monster Raving Loony Party), Rob Kenyon (Reform UK), Robert Pownall (independent), Rebecca Shepherd (Restore Britain), Sarah Wakefield (Green Party), Peter Ward (Rejoin EU Bring in PR) and Michael Winstanley (Conservative).