PART 2: Wigan Athletic: The 12th Man - 'Why do I get the feeling this is going right down to the wire?'
Our panel of Latics experts run the rule over Gary Caldwell’s first couple of games in charge, as he has the virtual luxury of a fortnight without a midweek game to get to know his new group of players ahead of the run-in.
Martin Tarbuck:


Why do I get the feeling this is going right down to the wire? Doesn’t it always where Wigan Athletic is concerned? I do feel a lot more confident now Gary Caldwell is in charge instead of Ryan Lowe, but he probably has at least half a hand tied behind his back between now and May.
Challenge No.1 is a particularly tough set of initial fixtures.


Challenge No.2 is that the transfer window is now closed.
Challenge No.3 is that, even when the transfer window was open, we hardly strengthened the right areas with the right players.
Challenge No.4 is that, in the new world of Wigan Athletic austerity-lite, we were hardly blessed with quality and strength in depth in the first place.
Challenge No.5, linked to challenge No.4, is that he has inherited a savage long-term injury list. Players like Ryan Trevitt, who played under Caldwell before, and an absent James Carragher and Will Aimson at the back. Even Jonny Smith is crocked, if we needed someone to come in off the wing and curl in a worldie aftera cheeky recall.


Challenge No.6 is that we have a squad that appears to have lost the ability to attack and defend, or even pass the ball directly to each other over the past 11 months, and that is going to take some re-training.
Challenge No.7 is that we have a very ill-disciplined side, prone to picking up yellow and red cards for the most petulant of reasons.
And challenge No.8 is having to manage the expectations and get onside with a fanbase that are tetchy at the best of times, due to our constant boom and bust existence, and are more used to being at the top end of the table, not the bottom.
Did I miss anything?


So not much to contend with then, and you have to wonder what perilous future lies ahead for poor Exeter City, given a meticulous man like Caldwell probably knew all this before he joined. Yet he still jumped at the chance to ditch mid-table stability at a club which appreciated him to move to a club in relegation turmoil, a perpetual state of chaos and on the precipice of returning to the fourth tier of English football for the first time in more than 20 years. I can therefore only conclude he is as much of a masochist as the rest of us.
I think we are going to see a lot of games like we saw at Stockport on Saturday in the coming weeks. Games where the intent is there, the passion and drive is there to get this club out of the muck, and there is some semblance of a plan. Yet it is going to take a gargantuan effort for this threadbare, vulnerable squad to deliver against that plan against tougher, stronger opposition like Huddersfield and Bradford.
To contradict this, however, we have already played Cardiff and Lincoln twice (looks like poor Ryan also fell foul of unfortunate fixture timing) and the team in third, so teams like Stockport, Huddersfield and Bradford are arguably the hardest ones we will face over the coming weeks. Oh, and a resurgent Plymouth.
Whereas we perhaps went into the game against County not expecting a win, the way we set off implied we had a very good chance before the two miscreants blotted their copybook again and threw away any chance of even a point. It must have taken a lot out of Stockport beating nine men 4-2, however, given they got thumped 3-0 at Burton midweek!


Perhaps bad news for us at the bottom of the table, but more importantly, it’s a sign that Stockport isn’t all that great. It also shows that anyone can beat anyone in this division if we can just get our act – and our discipline together.
Saturday's test is tougher because Joe Taylor is ineligible to play against his parent club. I have hatched a Baldrick-style cunning plan, whereby we could dye his hair ginger and put the name Luke Robinson on the team sheet, but I fear that it might be harder to get away with playing a ringer in League One. I mean the refs won’t notice - as incompetent as they are - but Huddersfield Town might, even if he prowls the top end of the pitch pretending to be a Scouser and saying 'alright la, sound, cushty innit'.
On a serious note, I guess we probably need to work on our defence this week, on the basis our main goal threat is out. With the obvious challenge being there...that we only have a limited number of fit defenders. I wonder what has happened to the aforementioned Luke Robinson who, although not a wing back, can certainly defend. Whoops sorry I forgot he dyed his hair blonde at Christmas and has been playing up front (if any Hudds fans are reading)…
In summary, despite all the challenges Caldwell faces, all we need to happen on Saturday is for Huddersfield to have an off day, Sam Tickle to have a blinder (not unusual), our players to keep our discipline, and probably a clean sheet while we nick something up front off Christian Saydee’s bum cheek, to give us the spawniest 1-0 victory the Brick Community has ever seen. It’s unlikely, but we’re Wigan Athletic, we beat the odds, right?
Finally, in other news on Saturday, and a shameless plug, Mudhutter issue 95 hits the streets this weekend and will be on sale at the game. I’ve no idea how we got this far, and we’ve no intention of stopping. It is somewhat reassuring that our sales continue to hold up, at a time when print media has all but fallen away. So thank you, whether you read it regularly or occasionally, you keep us going!
George Arkwright:
Lofty highs and crushing lows...what a week it has been since the triumphant return of our lord and saviour, Gary Caldwell.
I’ve met Gary on a few occasions through my work with Exeter City Football Club. He’s sorely missed by the Grecians, and I’ve heard nothing but good things about him since his previous tenure with us ended.
To say I was pleased with his appointment would be an understatement. With the dignity of his former mentor Roberto Martinez, and the fire and passion that comes with his Scottish heritage, he feels like the perfect fit for this side. I am genuinely excited to see where we can go under his guidance.
That said, with less than a day on the training pitch before his first game at home to Luton, it felt like something of a free hit. We looked in poor shape and, with 15 games to play, I was still confident we’d find a way out of the predicament we’d landed ourselves in, under his stewardship.
A hard-fought, well-earned 1–0 win followed, and I left buoyed by a performance we simply haven’t seen enough of this season. The goal was well worked. The endeavour and resilience were there in abundance. We defended as though the very fabric of the club depended on it.
Will Aimson had his best game of the campaign. Joe Taylor looked every inch the Championship striker we know him to be. The entire side looked more structured, more composed, and far clearer in its identity. I couldn’t fault any of them, and they’d fully earned that rather pointed full-time photo opportunity. And this wasn’t even a game in which we’d beaten the gaffer’s former team yet! I can only imagine the scenes when we do, come March.
Fast-forward to Stockport, and once again it felt like a free hit. I didn’t truly expect us to win but, after such a sterling showing the week before, I quietly hoped we might take something. Stockport’s form had wobbled - albeit against stronger opposition than we’d posed - until recently.
As the cliché goes, it was a game of two halves. For the first 45 minutes, I would’ve backed us wholeheartedly. Two well-taken goals by Taylor and, though we went in level at the break, it felt like we’d established a foothold we could build on.
Yes, we looked slightly fragile at the back without Aimson, Carragher, and several other defensive regulars, but aside from a couple of wobbles - and conceding twice, of course - we looked the more competent side. Unfortunately, that assessment didn’t survive the interval.
Steven Sessegnon, having just watched Dara Costelloe receive a yellow card for a shirt-pull barely 90 seconds earlier, decided to replicate the act on the hour mark. The result was inevitable: his marching orders. It was baffling. Perhaps his spell out of the side under previous leadership left its mark on his decision-making.
What began as a promising afternoon quickly became damage limitation and stalwart defence. To their credit, the remaining 10 defended resolutely despite the long list of absentees. Young Llyton Chapman came on for his debut and looked composed and assured. But we came unstuck in the 92nd minute. Then, in the 94th, Maleace Asamoah Jnr sealed our fate with a challenge that defied logic. A goal down, studs up, full pace, straight through their right winger. It was reckless and deservedly punished.
Down to nine, the goal that followed had felt inevitable. We left Stockport empty- handed, chastened, and with little to show for the effort. That appearance proved to be Asamoah Jnr’s last in a Wigan shirt this season, as he has since been loaned out to Shamrock Rovers.
A word on him: I do believe there’s a player there. He’s young, clearly talented, but raw to the point of self-sabotage at times. A spell away from the spotlight, in a side expected to win and operating near the top of their league, may prove invaluable.
A slightly lower standard of opposition, paired with high expectations, might be exactly what he needs. It will either shape him or stall him - and I hope it’s the former. I’d like to see him mature, grow, and return to us improved both on and off the pitch.
Back to the present. If you’d asked me on the Monday of Caldwell’s appointment whether I’d take three points from the opening two games, I’d have said 'yes' without hesitation. Yet the table tells a harsher story. Burton and Doncaster have found form and, despite our win, we sit in a worse position than before.
We saw many positives in these first two games - perhaps the best and worst of our team in quick succession. We haven’t played badly and I feel, although there are areas for improvement, we already look much the better team...more than capable of success.
But we desperately need a reaction. Huddersfield are beatable. We’ll be without Taylor, Asamoah Jnr, and several other key players, but I still believe this squad has enough. We’ve seen the flashes of quality. Under the right tutelage, the more inhibited elements of this team can be unlocked.
We’ve been here before. Great Escapes are part of the modern Wigan identity. We are not out of the mire - nowhere near, if we’re honest - but the ingredients are there. With the right application, mentality, a slice of luck, and a healthy dose of quality, I still believe in the Latics. And come May, I still expect Gary Caldwell’s blue-and-white army to be secure enough to spend the summer in the comfort of mid-table mediocrity...a luxury that’s eluded us for the better part of two decades.
Soccerates:
They say you should never go back but, as Gary Caldwell strode into the Brick Community Stadium last week, the air felt undeniably different.
After the tactical stagnation and 'safety-first' football that defined the end of the previous regime, the 'Second Coming' of our FA Cup-winning hero has brought more than just a wave of nostalgia...it has brought a visible, aggressive identity back to the club.
While the results on paper look like a mixed bag - a gritty, heart-pumping 1-0 win over Luton followed by a chaotic 4-2 defeat at Stockport - the 'eye test' tells a far more promising story. Under Caldwell, we are finally seeing a side that looks 'connected'.
In his opening games, the shift to a more fluid 3-4-2-1 system has allowed our wing-backs to actually influence the game rather than just cover ground. The sideways passing has been replaced by a demand for intensity. We are hunting in packs again and, for the first time in months, the players look like they actually enjoy having the ball at their feet.
But perhaps the most vital change hasn't been the formation, but the dug-out. Caldwell hasn’t arrived alone - he has curated a backroom staff that perfectly blends 'Latics DNA' with modern tactical precision.
The return of Peter Atherton as assistant head coach provides a steel and local understanding that is already rubbing off on the back three. Beside him, the appointment of David Perkins as first-team coach has been a masterstroke for morale.
'Perks' was a dynamo on the pitch, and he’s proving to be just as combustible on the touchline - his yellow card against Luton was greeted with a roar of approval from the stands that felt like a goal in itself. It’s that fire we’ve been missing.
Furthermore, the addition of Lauren Jones to the analysis department (rejoining Caldwell from their successful stint at Exeter) signals this isn't just a trip down memory lane. It’s a professional, data-driven operation designed to ensure we don't just survive this season, but build a platform for the next.
Caldwell himself admitted he is a vastly different man and manager than the rookie who led us to the title ten years ago. He speaks of 'clearer pictures' and 'simplicity', and it’s showing. Even in the defeat at Stockport, the first-half performance was some of the most attractive football we’ve played all season.
We are currently 22nd, and the road to safety will be long and likely winding. But with a coaching trio that understands the weight of the badge and a manager who has replaced fear with a license to play, the 'Believe' posters don't feel like marketing anymore , they feel like a plan.
Results might be a mixed bag for now but, for the first time in 2026, the Latics are fun to watch again. And in this league, that's often where the Great Escapes begin...