PART ONE: Wigan Athletic: The 12th Man - 'It could be a while before we undo the mess created...'
In the first of another two-part bumper 12th Man, our panel of Latics observers pick up the pieces following the departure of Ryan Lowe...and plot a route out of the League One drop zone...with the small matter of an FA Cup trip to Arsenal in the meantime!
Alan Rogers:


Well this is a first...being allowed to spout garbage twice in one week! But obviously, there's a lot to talk about at the moment. We had the disgraceful result on Saturday afternoon, followed by the inevitable, long-awaited dismissal on Saturday evening. Then the real fun started!
The vast majority seemed to agree that this was the right decision, but then the internet started throwing up random possible replacements. Social media is a weird place at best, but the 'debate' over Lowe's replacement plumbed new depths. Random names thrown out into the ether were immediately shot down, or occasionally supported. What a pointless, utter waste of time.
For one thing, the fans can't agree on a favourite among themselves and, even if they did, there's no way that anyone would listen to the fans. I mean, we've only been saying for months that Lowe was the wrong man...
Personally, I have no real preference for our next head coach. If possible, I really would like him to have some former affinity with our club, but also maybe possess some of the traits that our last Supreme Leader didn't. A touch of humility perhaps and the ability to connect with the fans would go a long way to building a few bridges.
And reverse the dug-outs! I mentioned a while ago that Uwe Rosler was the only other person to change the seating arrangements around...and look what happened to him! Call it superstition, call it tradition, but let's put things back how they were.
The editor of this feature published an excellent summary of Lowe's tenure earlier this week. I hope some of the people who slag off our local press took the time to read it. Not only did it reveal some damning facts about Lowe, it also more than hinted how difficult it can be for a local newspaper to work with some people. Lowe wouldn't even give out his mobile number!
As soon as the sacking was announced, most supporters realised the fans' forum probably wouldn't go ahead. What would be the point when a central character would be absent? But some 'experts' were outraged! Why couldn't the event still take place, so we could then spend some time abusing Gregor Rioch and the board? Unbelievable! But the strange thing is...the main complainants were anonymous characters, who definitely didn't have tickets for the event anyway!
On to the next game, and Tuesday night didn't start well. A miserable evening, and the hoped-for upsurge in home support didn't happen, meaning a very quiet concourse and empty seats. But the mood was definitely more upbeat, and the players seemed to respond.
The first half was very encouraging, lots of effort and some glimpses of what we've been missing. However, in the second half, Reading kicked up a gear and, although we tried valiantly to match them, once again we were undone by defensive mistakes. Lowe may be gone, but it could be a while before we undo the mess he created. He ruined a decent defensive set-up - in addition to his other many mistakes - and we have a huge hill to climb.
Moving on to next weekend...after Saturday's result, I had a real fear about Sunday's game. With Lowe in charge, I definitely felt a disaster was looming...a defeat of unrivalled proportions, and it would have been so unnecessary. Thousands of fans have bought tickets, and initial excitement had turned to dread for the majority of those supporters.
Most of my family will be in attendance, but I've been banned. Not because of the nonsense I write in here, but because I've got a DVT in my leg. All under control, thank you (before you start arranging my requiem), but the doctor wouldn't allow me to spend all day on a coach.
Before last Saturday, I really wasn't bothered - I was almost relieved! - but now I'm gutted to miss potentially another massive day in our history. I saw enough on Tuesday night to hope that at least they will play with a bit more pride. Good luck lads, and safe travel to everyone involved!
Martin Lally:
Well it’s been some week... The loss of Ryan Lowe, and the honest truths that have raised their head since his departure, is shocking. It’s getting harder to believe who at the top was keeping him in a job?
As for the fans forum being scrapped? This club is doing nothing but continuing to disappoint. The fans deserved answers and explanations, and my honest opinion is they didn’t want to face it. I believe I was correct in suggesting the forum gave them two weeks of breathing space, and I find it hard to believe they ever planned to hold it in the first place.
Work took me away from Wigan unfortunately on Tuesday, but I did catch the game on TV. It’s obviously great to see Jason Kerr back, and the first 20 minutes we looked great. The disallowed goal looked close, but when you’re down there not much goes for you. And that was the mantra of the entirety of the game in the end.
We seriously can’t defend free-kicks and consistently gifted them to the opposition...Huddersfield (a), Doncaster (a) and now Reading (h). Fraser Murray looked good, and Joe Taylor is slowly becoming a fans favourite, but the truth is - despite Lowe's absence - we still look like a bottom four team. And without a severe upturn in form we are going to go.
So on to Arsenal on Sunday...and you know we will probably win! It takes you back to the final in 2013 against Manchester City, when all I wanted was for us to compete on the day. The same can be said of Sunday. The FA Cup gave us our greatest day, but we would be foolish not to say that our focus really needs to be on league survival. And as it stands we look down and can’t buy a win.
The new manager selection is the biggest decision this club will make in the 20 years just gone and the 20 years to come...and it must come quickly. Just the 16 cup finals to come…
Tony Moon:
As the head gardener leaves, it becomes the responsibility of his assistants who are left to tend to the plants, flowers, succulents, cacti, bulbs and seeds. Some have been given far too little water and are in desperate need of hydration. Some however have been overwatered and appear half-drowned. Others have been planted far too deep - or too shallow - and just need repotting. Some of course are in the wrong type of soil completely, and need to be positioned elsewhere in the garden.
We saw that the assistants recognised some of this and with a little pruning, started to make the whole garden a little more presentable. Let’s not kid ourselves though. We might be going to the Arsenal this year, but we certainly aren’t off to Chelsea (Flower Show). Still, it'll soon be spring, when everything starts to look better, and as we all know, that’s when the WAFC garden starts to flourish…
George Arkwright:
Rome wasn’t built in a day. But it was potentially torn down between September and February. And I don’t think anyone is under the misapprehension that there is a quick fix for the predicament that we now find ourselves in.
We were all buoyed, relatively, by the appointment of Ryan Lowe back at the beginning of last year. I think his tenure has contextualised just how far we still have to go to return to even the period slightly after the glory years.
The club, lest we forget, has been through the most turbulent time of pretty much any in the EFL or beyond since 2020...notwithstanding the ones that regrettably went out of business as a result. One and almost another administration, inches from a ‘wrapping up’ order from HMRC, bad-faith actors from all corners of the globe looking to make a quick buck from us only to then discard us like a prime minister’s inconvenient association.
We have certainly been through the ringer, and I think that even years on, we forget that when it comes to the short, medium and long term running of our club. As we have noted at various points this year, the inexperience within parts of our upper management has been evident. That is not to say they are incapable...rather, they lack the seasoned judgement and quiet nuance that only years in the role tend to cultivate. Put simply, they’re learning on the job. And we simply no longer have the resources for it to be any other way.
Almost immediately, it is possible to question that - we have a billionaire as an owner but, until he has seemingly recouped on his losses, or has cleaned the slate in terms of our running costs, debt and associated spends, it doesn’t look as though we’ll be mounting a Manchester City-style world-domination run any time soon.
Instead, we are to cut our cloth accordingly. The point that’s being made is one of pragmatism. We are no longer a wealthy club in this division. We are unfortunately no longer a particularly successful one at this moment in time. But all of this comes against a backdrop of absolute apocalypse.
We were so close to not existing at all. We have made it out of that period intact and so, to an extent, this latest managerial capitulation feels like nothing more than a blip...an aftershock of things preceding. What we do need now is belief - more than ever. We have a squad that on their day can produce moments of magic, albeit we haven’t seen many this year.
The game against Reading was seemingly an improvement in terms of quality and endeavour, and you would hope that, with enough time, an astute managerial appointment and a bit of luck, we can ride the storm through to the end of the season and recoup.
It is all well and good lamenting a season wasted, an inept directorial team, the glistening teeth of a manager doomed to the annals of history; missed opportunities, dark days and closed kiosks.
But looking forward is all that the club can do now. We must rally behind and push forward, not lag behind and harken for the past. The only way that our great club will return to what we all deem its rightful position is with positivity, aptitude, resilience and a monstrous amount of hard work.
To speak, lastly, on managerial appointments...Graham Barrow and Glenn Whelan can be commended for stepping into the breach after the ejection of their former leader. But to look to them for stability is potentially a bridge too far.
Barrow has paid his dues and deserves to be on the beach by this point. The fact that we’re asking so much of a man that has already given and given is a testament to his character and to his dedication to the club.
Whelan? Well the jury's out there, but he has shown glimpses of managerial potency that his superior potentially didn’t. Still, I'm not sure he’s the right man for the job.
I have spent this article telling us not to look backwards but forward, and yet I think that having someone with Wigan in their DNA is paramount at this moment. Someone to steady the ship. Someone who binds himself to the supporters and restores belief where cynicism has taken root.
Someone who can rekindle goodwill and act as the adhesive holding club and crowd together until the time comes to stride confidently into whatever comes next after these fractious years. Someone with managerial experience. Someone who has tasted success. Someone accustomed to leading - in the dressing room and beyond it.
Someone who has learned from the very best. Someone forged in great sides - in our greatest side. Someone whose charisma is unmistakable, whose passion requires no amplification. Someone unafraid to wear his heart on his sleeve, yet measured enough to channel it. Someone who believes in Wigan Athletic as much as he believes in himself and in those he leads.
And if he happened to be Scottish? Well, that wouldn’t hurt either.