Wigan Athletic: The 12th Man - 'We need as much alignment as possible across all areas'
Our panel of Latics observers reflect on a disappointing trip down to Reading, ahead of the always important Easter period which could shape the season of many clubs...including Gary Caldwell’s side...
Matt Auffrey:


A major theme of my submission last week was to highlight the success we’ve experienced under Gary Caldwell through his first eight games in charge. As I transitioned the focus of my piece from past to future and looked ahead at our trip to Reading, I nearly labelled the fixture a ‘free hit’.
With the exception of our trip to Stevenage on the final day of the season (where we should hopefully be on the beach), the Reading match represented our toughest shot at a win over our final run of eight games. The odds of us winning were surely going to be lower than those of any remaining fixture.
However, given that we were still in the thick of a relegation battle, I felt it was common sense to expect a competitive performance - even against a prominent bogey team of recent years. Maybe, my glass was too half-full. One of our worst efforts of the season ensued.
I can thank my out-of-town family who visited New York City last weekend for dragging me out of my home on Saturday to partake in tourist activities and avoid viewing the two hours of disappointment that took place at the Select Car Leasing Stadium.
The greatest saving grace of the day was that Caldwell reminded us during his post-match press conference that we recently bounced back from the let-down that was the 3-0 home defeat against Plymouth. We responded from that debacle with a commanding 2-0 victory against Bradford just four days later. Surely, there is reason to believe we will respond over Easter.
Finally, I want to commend the club for releasing an excellent 20-minute interview with Sarah Guilfoyle to discuss many important updates regarding the current state of the club. There have been many shortcomings in past communication, but the right precedent was set with this video.
Hopefully, we continue to receive updates in a similar engaging format on at least a quarterly basis. If this club is ever going to progress consistently upward, we need as much alignment as possible across all areas.
The best way to keep momentum going off-the-pitch is by stringing positive results together on the pitch. We can't let one bad result take away from the feel-good factor that has been steadily building over the past month and a half.
Some massive home fixtures remain, and we should expect to win each one. The ‘Believe Bus’ should have just enough petrol left to get us through this final stretch!
George Arkwright:
Let’s be honest, we all saw it coming. As positive as things have been around the Brick over the last few weeks, inevitably all good things must come to an end. And end they did, in quite spectacular fashion, against a promotion-pushing Reading side.
We’ve never travelled well down to the Royals - finding ourselves on the end of quite a few 2–0 defeats in recent years. And while there was hope that Gary Caldwell’s relatively triumphant return would see a streak of three consecutive defeats overturned, in reality they are flying high and we were probably due a slip-up.
Thankfully, this game was something of a free hit. We have seven more than winnable games coming up in the run-in and, if we can look to pick up points from our next two or three, you’d hope that come May we’ll be home and dry.
However, this game did leave some questions - particularly around our defensive frailties, and our ability to deal with a tactic that has been used against us all season to relative effect - the high press.
Our performance was defined by unforced errors. We seemed to lose pretty much every second ball we challenged for, and on so many occasions errant passes or touches left the ball to be picked up in dangerous areas.
Situations that, in previous games, would’ve seen us break and counter with slick passing instead left us exposed to an onslaught of chances - two of which they took in very similar fashion - and we found ourselves essentially out of the game by the half hour.
Our defence looked uncomfortable with the pace and strength of their forward line, and we did nothing to combat the long balls they were playing - bypassing our midfield and isolating both centre-backs, neither of whom had their best game in a Wigan shirt.
Our wing-backs struggled to nullify their overlapping full-backs, and we were constantly left scrambling and on the back foot, with Ryan Nyambe having a stellar game...it’s a real shame he didn’t know how to do that for us.
I think it also pointed out our lack of attacking diversity. Joe Taylor had a rare quiet game and, unfortunately, there seemed to be no one else willing to step into his - admittedly very big - shoes. Harrison Bettoni looked flat and was hooked relatively early and, without Matt Smith and Caylan Vickers on the pitch, we looked lacking in creativity and forward momentum.
Generally, we looked shambolic, and this is something Gary needs to address as soon as possible. It’s all well and good losing the occasional game. We are near the bottom of the league and, although form has turned a corner, we are still where we are.
I don’t think anyone is under the misapprehension that we were going to end the season unbeaten. But the way we have capitulated in games under Caldwell’s tutelage is vaguely worrying. We aren’t just being outperformed, we’re getting absolutely thrashed and leaving without even our pride intact.
Don’t get me wrong, I think they played very well. And I’m struggling to understand the unease at Reading around Leam Richardson’s tenure. They looked every bit the play-off hopefuls that they are.
But if we continue with this inconsistency, what could be a reasonably straightforward push for survival could yet end in horror. The teams around us are all performing as well and, if we continue to make mistakes like we did on Saturday, we will find ourselves in trouble.
There is also the question of the season beyond. I am still quite confident we will be safe come the final day, but that still leaves us in a problematic position. With the vast majority of our squad out of contract at the end of the season, we could be looking at a comprehensive rebuild come June - putting ourselves at risk of losing key figures among our younger, more talented players.
We also have the least potent strike force we’ve had for quite a while, with Christian Saydee and Dara Costelloe amounting to very little this season. Without Taylor, we look pretty toothless and, assuming we’re not keeping him, we’re going to have to put our hands in our pockets and find someone capable of replacing, even in part, the contributions he has made.
The run-in is positive. Our fortunes do seem to have changed. Maybe this is simply a ghost from the previous regime. But either way, this felt like a reminder...that for all the progress we’ve made, nothing is secure yet. And if we don’t cut out the errors quickly, we risk undoing that progress just as fast.
truelatic4eva:
It currently feels like two steps forward and one step backward. The Reading game was like stepping back three months to the Lowey era.
I have total faith in Gary Caldwell, but I don't have the same faith in (some) of the players who unfortunately let everyone down on Saturday. To say it wasn't good enough would be the understatement of the year.
On to Thursday, hopefully with a reaction from the players - and three more points towards safety. This summer will see a massive turnaround of players, which is frankly needed.
Billy Haggerty:
Reading the room, it seemed like it was a few pages too far for Latics to go way down south to play Leam Richardson's Reading. Maybe the writing was on the wall, as we have a poor record against these men.
It seemed we authored our own demise, with Reading's man of the match Will Aimson, displaying hapless moment...after woeful defending, he followed up with a blinding mis-header, leading to a textbook own goal.
We huffed and puffed for the majority of this game and, despite the odd passage of play, the writing was on the wall yet again...and that we'd suffer another defeat against Reading. Now considering it was an easy-ish win for them, it was more like a library given the fairly quiet home fans. The defeat was a non-fiction read, we were second in every department, no fight for the second ball, sitting off players, and a lack of fight gifted them the three points.
The fiction book reads like this...some of these players think they're better than they are. Take note, Latics - we could still be in trouble. We aren't safe from relegation. In the fiction book chapter two...we could be sold, a new owner could plough millions into us making us the next Wrexham, and we could march on up the leagues. As I say, it's a fiction book, but who knows? It could even become a bestseller.
The non-fiction book reads like this....Mr Danson, without a bit of reasonable funding, League One is our best outcome, and could possibly lead to a spell in League Two. The non-fiction book says we need to get our act together, gather enough points to secure our status as a League One club, and get some players signed in readiness for next season, otherwise it could be another cliffhanger.
In the here and now, we have a big Easter looming large, so hopefully we can put the dismal Reading performance behind us and put on a 'could do better' report and gather some much-needed points.
All that said, reading between the lines, I feel a lot more confident with scholars Caldwell and Perkins at the helm and, if we go all out chapter and verse in the next few games, we'll be safe and sound and we can write off what's been a turbulent season.
So turn the page on my 12th Man piece, because I'm sure there will be far more interesting and informative reading to be had away from here…
Martin Lally:
Had to take a few days to reflect on Reading, and also warm up from the micro climate artic conditions inside the ground in comparison to the pleasanter conditions on exit. It’s a shame that Gary Caldwell's blue and white army didn’t warm up, because that was quite simply an absolute pants performance.
I have heard this week some complimentary comments about Reading, but I have to say that when a team simply plays a long ball, you don’t defend it, and then they put two balls in the box that lead to you being 2-0 down, you're always running up a hill.
It feels like every time we go to Reading these days, we are two down before we even think about competing...not a happy hunting ground of late. On the day we simply weren’t good enough, and it was totally on the players. There were performances on Saturday so absent from the previous weeks that it was hard to recognise us.
The fact (again) that Reading sit sixth in this league, and we were treated to numorous renditions of ‘Tottenham away’ by the home faithful, only shows for me how poor this league one season has been. We cannot think we are safe, because we are not.
Seven games left against pretty much everyone around us and, with the way results are going, we will need a minimum of two wins, maybe even three, to be guaranteed safety. But performances like Saturday will yield a treacherous pathway to May 2, where we really don’t want to be going to Stevenage needing anything.
So this week the board spoke, and the focus was on a new kit deal and an increase to season ticket prices. This is a step in the right direction but, from a personal perspective, I still believe the water under the bridge isn’t quite under the bridge. If the kit deal is with Kappa, I for one wouldn’t be in the slightest bit surprised. But one can live in hope.
Re season tickets, I understand. The club has to survive and the frozen prices have been good. I just hope they invest in deals that bring a future generation of Wigan Athletic fans to the club who want to be around for many years to come.
It’s starting to feel like a long season, as a fan I’m fatigued now, and I hope that Easter can deliver some kind results. There has been zero talk of contracts but, after Saturday, you wonder how many of them actually want to be here or are wanted by the club. And that’s sad for true fans, because we always want the best.
The board say there is a plan for League One survival and a plan for relegation. Ironically we were told that was an impossibility some time back but, as we all know, no team is too big to go down.
Two enormous games at Easter could ease the pressure, and ease the suffering of the devoted Tics Faithful Up the fatigued yet hanging in there Tics!
Tony Moon:
A poor performance, of that there’s no doubt; So the fuming has started, and the knives have come out.
According to some (and with little to cheer); It was the worst that we’ve played (for the 6th time this year!).
After matches like this, hyperbole rules; And the critics compete in the contest of fools.
Who’s most disgusted? And most disappointed? How can it be we appear so disjointed?
Social meeja critics tell us which players are poo; Even though we all care not a jot for their view.
So we’ve just lost a game, and to a decent team; But we’re "as good as relegated!, aye, we’re down it would seem.
But it gives us a chuckle when we think back to Lowe; And how poor we were then, just how “Lowe” could we go!
And since then, we’ve been sometimes hot, sometimes not; But at least we’ve climbed out of that relegation spot.
So instead of expecting a win every game; Why don’t we accept that survival’s the aim,
And so long as we win all our games at The Brick; We’ll end up just fine...cos at least we now ‘Tic!
