Wigan Athletic: The 12th Man - 'When things aren’t communicated and clarified, we make up our own reality'
Our panel of Latics experts use the international break to assess where their side stands after the first block of fixtures
Matt Auffrey:


Having missed last week’s submission, I want to start by offering my deepest condolences to the family and friends of Kevin Miller.
After taking some time to learn about Kevin as a player, a coach, and a person, it’s abundantly clear that a great man was taken from us far too soon. I can only imagine the hurt that is felt by Kevin’s passing within our changing room and coaches’ offices.
As glamorous as life in the professional sporting landscape can seem in this current day and age, it is still very demanding and full of sacrifices. A good coach can have a tremendous impact - on and off the pitch - especially for young players at a crucial stage in their development.
He surely provided great support for Gary Caldwell during their time together in Exeter and most recently at the Brick. The raw emotion the gaffer displayed while talking about his friend and colleague certainly tugged at my heart strings.
I lost a team-mate to a tragic incident during my adolescence, and it was a moment that greatly impacted the trajectory of my life from that point onward. I hope every player in the squad can draw on Kevin’s wisdom and spirit to make themselves a little bit better with each passing day.
As dire as the results have been so far this season, we know we are capable of playing much better - even if we are still a ways away from putting together a winning streak. Who knows what improving everyone’s individual performance by just five percent would do for our team success?
Overall, I'd rate our efforts across the first seven league fixtures a 2/10, and our performances over the first three cup fixtures (one in the Carabao and two in the Jersey Mike’s) a 7/10. Comparing results across all competitions against our expectations, the first two months of this new campaign equate to a 3/10 for me.
Nonetheless, I’ll be as ready as anyone for the first kick of the ball against Stevenage next weekend. While I am grateful that Latics have had ample time to regroup and recharge following a devastating loss, going forward, I would prefer as few breaks from the league fixture list as possible.
However, with plans to celebrate my wife’s birthday this coming weekend, maybe it’s best for our household that Latics won’t have an opportunity to dampen my mood and, in turn, the upcoming festivities. But come 10 in the morning New York time next Saturday, I’ll be champing at the bit to hop back on this season’s emotional roller coaster again.
George Arkwright:
Just when you thought it was safe to get out from behind the sofa… yet more Wigan Athletic-related drama!
Anthony Cole-Johnson, we hardly knew yee. After a heady, stunted two months in the job, it seems as though personal circumstances have cut short a relationship laced with controversy from the off.
When choosing a successor to Sarah Guilfoyle; a figure who held much favour with the Wigan faithful and placed community outreach at the heart of her tenure, the ownership group cited stability and commercial growth as the main remit.
Aside from a funeral home sponsorship, which in hindsight feels quite apt, and bleakly ironic, I’m unsure how much revenue generation we’ve seen in the last two months.
The community outreach has foundations of success, but again, how much can we really judge from less than a financial quarter in charge? Either way, stability and solidarity have also failed to materialise.
Much has been made by many in the fanbase of the failings of simple business operations: delayed season tickets, sponsorship packages and a decline in the quality of the overall matchday experience.
These issues were assumed to be in the in-tray of our new CEO and, whilst we may have languished with them in the short term, the hope was that his appointment would ultimately bring a vast improvement in business operations overall.
However, after a month entrenched in bureaucratic limbo, Cole-Johnson has effectively been at his post for little more than a month in an official capacity, and in that time there has been little discernible change from a supporter’s perspective.
Maybe in his next and final month we will see something resembling reform, but that would frankly make this latest bitter disappointment in a string of bitter disappointments all the more bitter.
‘Top six on and off the field’ was the eventual aim, allegedly. And yet, this instability simply resets a club in dire need of respite.
If there’s no one in charge, no one willing to steady the ship and build a platform for sustained growth, how on earth do we expect it to happen?
It speaks to either the ultimate bad luck or naivety of the people running the club. To rid us of someone so involved in our community as Guilfoyle, only to replace her with someone who presides over us for barely any time at all before moving on, paints a pretty bleak picture.
I’m sure he and the owners have not acted nefariously; I don’t think there is a plot to sink the good ship Latics through a procession of poor decision-making and frugality.
And yet here we are, once again rudderless in an ocean without a captain. Without direction, our club will continue to languish and stagnate.And as they say, momentum is everything when it comes to football. Right now, we feel like a club with none.
My hope is that it genuinely is a profound change in Anthony’s personal life that has caused his unceremonious departure, rather than the enormity of the task of making a success of our club.
I did not envy Lucas Danson ahead of the fans’ forum. There were accusations, borne out of anger, resentment and misery. He received tough questions, and I hope the answers were what ultimately we can believe in.
The next appointment is a big one. It is probably pivotal, in a period of many pivotal decisions that have gone awry.
I’ll keep the faith, but God; what a mess.
Billy Haggerty:


As I sit here on my holidays on the Greek island of Skiathos, I thought I'd give my overview of the season so far.
The travel to get here was turbulent, with lots of bumps and dips along the way. The dark blue skies of doom are blocking out any rays of sunshine, and the feeling of a big downpour on the horizon - perhaps even a rumble or two of thunder to come - makes most folk reluctant to venture out especially given the price of stuff...
Now that's enough about the Latics season review for the time being. And I'll concentrate on my holiday here in Skiathos...
It's much the same to be honest, sparse crowds (holidaymakers), the weather's a bit of a hit and miss (a bit like our strikers), and it's depressing when the expected sunshine fails to appear.Lots of similarities to the Latics season, to be honest. We've been the masters of failed expectations so far, zero striker threat and our only consistency is our inconsistency.
We looked devoid of any confidence at times & as soon as a goal goes in our heads drop. We are so slow getting out of our own half & seem more than content with that outlook.
Not a lot of urgency or attacking threat gives the opposition the upper hand which often leads to the inevitable goal against us.I feel for Gary Caldwell, as I'm sure he wasn't aware when taking up the role that he'd be so hampered and given little or none of the transfer money.
I'm hoping for a change in fortunes and style of play after the international break and we can become more consistent, find the back of the net, and play some decent attacking play...not too much to ask for, is it?
Anyway, I can hear Stavros calling my name, telling me I have another large Mythos being poured at the bar, so until the next instalment of the 12th Man...Yamas!
And for those of you thinking: 'why on earth is he writing a 12th Man piece while he's supposed to be on holiday?'...the simple answer is: the weather's a bit like the Latics attacking threat = awful, we've done the shops and trips, and I had half an hour to kill til Happy Hour at the bar!
Martin Lally:


It feels like the international break came at a time when we needed some time to reset, but it also couldn’t come at a worse time. We needed games to gather momentum in the league, and we needed to convert the luck and performances in the Sandwich Cup into league points.
This week's 12th Man is based on where we are as a club? I’m going to break my piece into three areas which I guess overlap - club, competition and community.
As a club, it feels worse than it ever has. As a long-term fan, I have never felt so disconnected from the club, with no clear idea of the direction.I do appreciate the club called a Fans Forum for this week, and perhaps it will change my opinion. But if the board continues with the same attitude, I believe the behaviours will continue in terms of the fans.
Remembers the Betari box model, where your attitude in turn affects your behaviour? This can also turn a corner in a positive direction, but I feel the club need to rebuild a bridge with the fans and it needs to happen fast. In terms of competition. We can’t be happy propping up League One but it’s the end of September, and nobody wins titles in September.
Now I’m not suggesting this is a possibility for us, but the club continues to promote youthful football under a very good management team.I know most of us are simply gutted at 5pm most Saturdays but, after reviewing the games so far, only Stockport have thumped us - and that was down to getting it wrong tactically, which can happen.
Wimbledon were awful and we battered them, but that last-minute goal built confidence in a struggling group that has since propelled up to the top six.Why couldn’t that be us by Christmas? We do have a good squad, but the striker problem is still the elephant in the room.
If Chris Saydee doesn’t work, why not recall young Adam Moseley from his very successful spell at Southport and give him a chance? At least he seems to know where the net is!It’s clear we won’t spend money on the type of striker we need in January, because the finances won’t allow it.
We continue to do well in the EFL Trophy, and the FA Cup is just around the corner, giving us multiple chances to keep building and hopefully find some momentum.
Finally...community. I do find it hard every week to hear the boos. I said it last week, you are more surprised if the boys receive positive support these days, and the problem is a lot of these lads are from an era where they do look at social media.
They do take that to heart, and we are simply not the community we used to be. It’s too easy now to slate a player or a performance on social media with no care or concern for who it hurts or who it affects.
We are a community of good people, and many give a lot of their own personal time to help and support the club at all levels. The argument is the performances on the pitch need to give us the passion to support the club, and I do understand that. But it’s a vicious circle that is getting us nowhere.
I honestly believe the Wigan community is better than this. We return in just over a week, and I haven’t seen anything from the club.Is this a sign of the times, or are we enjoying some time to reset? Who knows? But communication is key, and the winter is coming, let’s hope the fans forum calms the storm a little and the performances start to build with Christmas just around the corner.
John Walker:
Another week and another bombshell hits the club as the new CEO hands in his notice - we are fast becoming the laughing stock of the Football League.
One thing you can say about the last person in the job - Sarah Guilfoyle - is that she he was dedicated to the club. Granted, we don’t know the circumstances of the departure, but the fact he’s not lasted a month since being approved is still very worrying.
I'm not sure who will even want to take it on, because looking from the outside the club's in a mess.Only one person can answer the questions about what’s going on, and that’s the man himself Mike Danson. But fans are getting fed up of being told Mr Danson is a very quiet man who doesn’t talk publicly.
It’s all guesswork, because as fans we don’t get told anything that’s going on. So come on, Mr Danson, put out some statement telling us exactly what your plans are.
I play my part by buying my season ticket, season after season. You must play your part. Not really a lot to ask when die-hard fans like myself are saying the club's being run into the ground and is on the way to League Two.
It’s very worrying. From a very concerned lifetime fan.
Tony Moon:
It’s always the same. In all things in life, when things aren’t fully communicated, explained and clarified, we plebs make up our own reality.
Sometimes, we’re spot on, sometimes, we’re wider of the target than a...nah, that would be a cheap shot.
One thing’s for sure, though. With the sad departure of Sarah Guilfoyle - sad in the context that at least she was seemingly trying to provide substantive comms to the fans - and her replacement not even lasting as long as a Ryan Trevitt injury (okay, another cheap shot, but I reckon a fair one),
Lucas Danson had best be bringing his 'A' game to the Fans Forum. He’ll certainly have some very pointed questions to answer re the cost of pies and the state of the unpainted seats.
Never change Latics, never change.