Why Wigan Athletic man has bittersweet memories of the FA Cup - 'No-one wants a silver medal'

For Wigan Athletic assistant manager Glenn Whelan, the 2011 FA Cup final between Stoke City and Manchester City was one of the highlights of his career.

Not that the Dubliner - who won 91 caps for the Republic of Ireland - enjoys speaking about it.

Glenn Whelan has bittersweet memories of the FA Cup as a playerplaceholder image
Glenn Whelan has bittersweet memories of the FA Cup as a player

"When you grow up as a child, all you want to do is play in the FA Cup final," acknowledged Whelan. "I managed to do that, but we lost...so you don't want to talk about it as much.

"Looking back, it was a great day for the club and for my family. Just getting to the final was a big achievement. Our final was probably the semi-final, when we beat Bolton 5-0...that was our special day.

"I still think about the final...I do. I've never watched it back, because of the huge disappointment attached to it."

Even though City went into the game as overwhelming favourites, there was to be only one goal between the sides on the day.

"Everyone spoke about how well we played, we had chances," he said. "I remember Kenwyne Jones having a big chance, before Yaya Toure Toure scored the only goal after 74 minutes.

"Over the course of the game, they probably deserved to win. But you always look back on the chances you had.

"I also had 40 or 50 people over from Dublin...but because we lost, I didn't really want to speak to anyone after the game.

"Now I've finished playing, it's the one thing I look back on and wish I had...no-one wants a silver medal for being runners-up.

"It's hung up with my Stoke shirt, but it's not something you really want to talk about...I've been promoted four times, I'd much rather talk about that.

"Even my 91 caps for Ireland...I had some good days and some bad days...Euro 2012 was not so great, being in the Group of Death...but Euro 2016 was a lot better!"

Whelan's enduring disappointment puts into perspective Latics' own triumph over the same opposition two years later.

Again City went in as red-hot favourites, and again there was to be a late, later winner...but this time the underdog prevailed!

An achievement Whelan says should never be underestimated.

"Definitely not!" he said. "The thing with Wigan is they got the win over Manchester City, whereas we couldn't get it done.

"It's not even that long ago...what, 12 or 13 years ago? And you still see all the pictures as you walk around the stadium and the training ground.

"Obviously we've still got Cal Mac and Graham Barrow in the group, who were a big part of that day...and I'm sure they'll never have to buy a drink in Wigan ever again!"

Fast forward to present day, and it's Latics who are there to be shot at when League Two strugglers Barrow visit the Brick this weekend for a place in round three - and the chance of drawing the likes of City and the other Premier League giants.

"Look, it's the FA Cup, everyone wants to be in it, and get as far as they can," added Whelan.

"We know what the rewards are...especially with the third round coming up next...with the luck of the draw, who knows what can happen…

"If you speak to the lads in the dressing room, I'm sure they'll all have their favourites, in terms of teams they'd love to play against if they got the chance.

"Everyone would like a big day out at a massive stadium...I'm not too sure there's many of this group that will have played at one of the big Premier League grounds.

"But first and foremost, we can't look any further than Barrow, because they might be looking at Saturday as their cup final, on a former Premier League ground.

"Cup upsets happen all the time, and we need to make sure we're not on the receiving end this weekend.

"Come Sunday or Monday, and the draw for the third round is made...if we're not in it, and Barrow got a massive tie, we'd be so disappointed."

News you can trust since 1853
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice