Wigan Athletic: How they rated v West Brom

Paul Kendrick runs the rule over the Wigan Athletic side that lost 1-0 at West Brom in the FA Cup and delivers his report card...

By The Newsroom
Saturday, 5th January 2019, 8:33 pm
Updated Wednesday, 9th January 2019, 1:29 pm
Reece James
Reece James

Wigan Athletic (4-2-3-1):

Jamie Jones: 7 - Rare chance to impress and couldn’t have done any more, made a stunning save just before the goal, which he almost kept out, and confident in general play.

Nathan Byrne: 6 - Reverted to right-back after playing most of season further forward and slotted back in without fuss, although didn’t get forward as much as he would’ve liked.

Sign up to our daily newsletter

Cedric Kipre: 7 - Maintained his record of being the only player to feature in every matchday squad this term, nothing got past him.

Chey Dunkley: 8 - Stunning clearance off the line in the second half prevented a certain goal and did all right in other areas.

Kal Naismith: 5 - Clearly not totally comfortable at left-back, and crosses at the other end - for once - lacked their usual danger and consistency.

Callum Connolly: 5 - Didn’t have much joy in the centre of the park and was hooked at the three-quarter mark.

Lee Evans: 5 - An 11th-hour inclusion thanks to Gibson’s injury in the warm-up, and couldn’t make the most of the shooting chances that came his way.

Callum McManaman: 6 - Long-awaited start will have pleased fans, and started in effervescent fashion - could have had a goal and an assist inside 10 minutes - before fading.

Josh Windass: 7 - Restored to the starting line-up and general play was good, although needs to translate his undoubted ability into more of a goal threat.

Leo Da Silva Lopes: 5 - Decent first half-hour on only his second start for the club, found it tougher going for the next half-hour before his substitution.

Will Grigg: 6 - Handed the captain’s armband on his return to the side, denied by the goalkeeper with his only sight at goal, fed off scraps for the rest of the game.


* Reece James (for Da Silva Lopes, 57): 8 - Showed versatility in central midfield and looked anything but out of place, broke up Albion attacks and starting Wigan ones with ease. Could this be his new position? *

Gary Roberts (for Connolly, 66): 6 - An attacking move in the final quarter, but unable to get on the ball enough to make a difference.

Shaun MacDonald (for McManaman, 77): 6 - Great to see him back on the field after a difficult 18 months, did everything with his customary efficiency.

Subs not used:

Christian Walton, Joe Garner, James Vaughan (only three named).

Star Man: Reece James

West Brom (4-3-3): Bond; Holgate, Adarabioyo, Bartley, Townsend; Brunt, Field, Harper; Hoolahan, Sako, Leko.

Subs: Fitzwater, Palmer, Howkins, Robson-Kanu (for Leko, 78), Morrison (for Harper, 87), Mears, Edwards (for Hoolahan, 72).

Shots on target: 5-2

Shots off target: 5-4

Corners: 3-7

Possession (%): 62-38

Fouls conceded: 9-12

Yellow cards: 2-2

Red cards: 0-0

Attendance: 15,465

Referee: Keith Stroud