Wigan Athletic: The 12th Man - 'Building trust should be of the utmost priority'
Our panel of Latics observers run the rule over another eventful week at the club, which may now be up for sale as Gary Caldwell and the team tries their best to avoid relegation to the fourth tier.
Matt Auffrey:


The spring that propelled our ‘new manager bounce’ over the first four games of Gary Caldwell's return has completely uncoiled. On Tuesday evening, we produced our most toothless home display of the season, resulting in a 3-0 defeat by Plymouth. Our collective play was largely disjointed and the goals we conceded were very poor.
We’ve missed Morgan Fox in our back three for the past two games. Callum Wright’s midweek absence also left a glaring hole in the middle of the pitch. If we’ve learned anything over the past few matches it’s that we desperately need our best XI fit and available for this final run of games.
Credit to the gaffer for refusing to make excuses for the performance in his post-match interview after Plymouth. However, we are starting to make lethargic starts a habit. We will certainly be punished by play-off-chasing Bradford this weekend if we do not start Saturday’s match on the right foot.
While it would be great to focus all of our energy and attention on club happenings on the pitch, we have been alerted to recent off-pitch activities that have many fans questioning the club's future. The fact that Mike Danson and company are exploring the possibility of a sale should not be a total surprise. The club’s lack of communication and transparency on the matter - especially after being exposed by a credible industry source - is far more concerning.
The ongoing correlation between our disappointing results on the pitch and a disappointing level of communication from club leadership doesn’t make this recent development any easier to process. If the goal is to grow the business through the investment of the club’s most prized asset - its fanbase - then building trust should be of the utmost priority.
While the idea of securing a new majority owner who is more enthusiastic about leading the club’s charge up the pyramid is enticing, the fans deserve more from our current board, right here and right now. We’ve sunk back into the relegation places and the talk of ‘doom and gloom’ has reared its ugly head once again. With 11 matches left, there are still plenty of opportunities to work our way up the table and achieve survival, but we need a big response from the lads this weekend.
Hopefully the Joseph’s Goal walkers can inject some life into the team as they arrive at the Brick on Saturday after their 50-plus-mile trek to raise funds for one of the club’s most dear and special causes. Please shoot them a few quid to support their efforts if you are able.
Otherwise, we can only hope that the referee for Bradford can identify a handball in the penalty box when it occurs right in front of his eyes. The Plymouth defender who made the volleyball block to stop Joe Taylor’s goal-bound attempt on Tuesday should’ve been gifted a pair of goalie gloves and credited with a save. Needless to say, we’re due for some good fortune. Bring on Saturday!
Soccerates:
The news of a leaked investment memorandum from January has sent shockwaves through the fanbase but, once you get past the initial headlines, the real story isn't just about the money. It’s about the risk. We’ve heard the word 'stabilisation' used a lot lately but, looking at the terms currently being shopped around, we have to ask: what exactly is an investor being asked to buy?
When we talk about Wigan Athletic, we talk about history and heritage. But for a serious investor, the current deal looks less like a football club and more like a franchise. If you buy in on these terms, you don't own the stadium. You don't own the bricks and mortar. You are essentially paying for a badge, a spot in League One, and a lease.
In the world of high finance, being a 'tenant' in your own town is a massive red flag. It turns an investment into an act of charity and, while we’d all love a billionaire benefactor, most people with £25million to spare didn't get it by taking on 100 per cent of the risk for zero security.
Then there’s the infrastructure. We can put a brave face on it, but the reality is that the facilities at Christopher Park have been a 'hidden' problem for ages. The memorandum alludes to this. When a buyer looks at a training ground that is barely fit for purpose, they don’t just see a football pitch. They see a massive, looming bill. They see a facility that makes it harder to sign players and harder to keep them fit.
Asking for millions in working capital while handing over a training ground that needs immediate, heavy investment is a move that would make any sensible investor think twice. Perhaps the biggest issue in the whole memo is the squad. By the end of this season, we are looking at a situation where less than half a dozen first-team players are actually under contract. Imagine trying to sell a factory where all the machinery is repossessed in June.
That’s essentially the deal here. An investor coming in during May isn't buying a functioning team. They are buying a massive, expensive recruitment headache. Without the players, the 'intangible assets' of the club are walking out the door for free.
The reason this leaked memo is so concerning isn’t just the 'distressed' label. It’s that the terms don't seem to offer a way out. Investors don't mind risk, but they hate risks they can't control. To get a serious person to the table, the deal has to change.
Whether it’s bundling in the fixed assets or offering a clear path to owning the stadium, something has to give. A 20 per cent 'minority carrot' isn't enough to tempt someone into a situation where they are saddled with all the costs and none of the security.
We’ve seen enough 'confidence tricks' and 'rebuilds' that have overspent and left previous owners in peril. We don't need another temporary fix; we need a deal that actually makes sense for the person putting their hand in their pocket. If we don't get that, we aren't just looking at a difficult summer. We’re looking at a race to the bottom that none of us want to see.
Paul Harrison:
Just as we seemed to have turned a corner - buoyed by Gary Caldwell’s steadying hand, and some hard-fought results on the pitch - the rug has been pulled yet again. The news Mike Danson is seeking an exit shouldn't, in hindsight, be a total shock, but it certainly stings.
Taking a step back, the signs have been there from the start. We’ve known from the outset he is a rugby man at heart, and his tenure has been defined by a distinct lack of visibility or voice. However, the way the news broke at the beginning of the week is still jarring.
Once again, the 'Latics Way' involves mixed messaging: what is being disclosed to our local press appears to be at odds with the circulated memorandum seen by members of the national media. The board must surely have known that such a memo would eventually find its way into the public eye.
The inconsistency only fuels the anxiety. Would a new owner necessarily be bad news? When Danson took over in 2023, I was relieved. I accepted his preference for the Warriors, while assuming he understood the grim reality of League One finances.
I knew a 'sustainable' model meant cutting our cloth and ending the era of the 'charlatan spenders' who nearly cost us our existence. Given Danson's billionaire status, I’d hoped he could shoulder a modest annual loss while perhaps - just maybe - becoming invested enough in his hometown club to fund a Dave Whelan-esque push back toward the top flight (a man can dream).
That optimism has waned significantly over the last two years. The silence from the owner and his son has been deafening, especially during moments where leadership was desperately required. The 18-month vacuum before appointing a permanent chief executive/managing director felt like an eternity.
I am less inclined to buy into the 'managed decline' narrative regarding finances. The books show that Danson continues to fund the club’s weekly operations to a substantial degree. The 'Thelo money' likely barely touched the sides of the significant sums he has injected since the 2023 takeover.
The real concern isn't if he's spending, but how it's being spent - and who is being trusted to steer the ship. Whatever happens next, Danson has a vested interest in a successful Wigan Athletic. We may no longer own the Brick Community Stadium, but the facility relies on the football club remaining a viable tenant.
My biggest fear - the one that will keep fans awake in the coming months - is the 'who next?' Danson saved us from the brink but, in seeking an exit, he risks leaving us vulnerable once more. We’ve (just about) survived the Yeungs and the Al-Jasmis of this world. We can only pray the next custodian values the soul of the club as much as the balance sheet.
Martin Lally:
Well it certainly looks different than it did a month ago, but in some regards it looks the same, unfortunately. This is especially true after our return to the bottom four following Tuesday night's poor performance against Plymouth Argyle.
I have to be honest, and even I had consigned myself to the prospect that we were bound for League Two football next year. Personally, having attended 73 of the 92 grounds, I was looking at the silver lining of a return to the fourth tier of English football, thinking a successful haul of away days in the 2026/27 season could elevate me closer to 85 grounds completed. But really I would have always preferred to stay in League One.
Despite the positivity of the new manager bounce, losing so heavily at home to Plymouth is a tough one to take, despite the fact they are in a rich vein of form. We are nowhere near out of the mire, but credit must go to Gary Caldwell overall. Perhaps he’s Superman after all. Only time will tell in this next month. But he owns it in the interviews, and it’s still certainly different to the previous regime. I am still perplexed by how long the change took, but I’m also still trying to balance my views of the board by leaving it in the past where it belongs. That said, we still haven’t seen an explanation regarding the fans' forum!
Back to Gary, and the team looks resoundingly different, like the team we all knew they could be. But slowly, the hangover of the Ryan Lowe era could be starting to hit us - like a bad Sunday morning after the Saturday night before - especially with games like Plymouth, where it certainly seemed like we had taken multiple steps backwards.
Fantastic wins at home against Luton and Huddersfield - regardless of how they arrived - take that bit of pressure off a little. Stockport was such a distorted result that last Saturday at Blackpool we probably saw where we actually now are...a severely low end League One club fighting for the right to even be at this level next season.
Sadly we seem to still struggle with silly fouls that lead to set pieces that lead to us losing goals in games. The equaliser at Blackpool was arguably deserved, and then a dogfight to the end where we maybe had the better of the opportunities.
But you can’t follow that up with a 0-3 loss at home, especially when others are fighting for their lives. After the Plymouth loss, we now probably need to be aiming for four points in this next week somehow, and unfortunately that’s piled a lot of pressure on the team.
Looking at the table, Port Vale's FA Cup adventure seems to have been a distraction, but they still have the top six as it stands to play...a tough run-in as well as a sixth-round tie. Our closest rivals - Northampton, Rotherham and Leyton Orient - also have at least two of the current top six to play.
For us, it seems to be in our hands, similar to Blackpool who also have, on paper, what appears more favourable fixtures. But you can’t take it away from Gary and Perks. They having given us hope and belief where it was simply empty and lost in the last regime, and I just hope we haven’t now ran out of steam.
They say 50 points is enough to survive, so we need four wins from 11 games if this is to be the case...fully emphasising how important the next week could be. All that aside, it’s a country mile from where we were. Until you read reports that the Danson family want to sell the club.
Honestly, the communication from the top is so poor, it’s incredible. I appreciate every club is maybe 'up for sale', but we are certainly a fanbase that deserves a minimum of honesty and transparency. The plan seems to becoming more and more clear that perhaps it was more about the Brick Community Stadium than the actual club itself? We can’t say honestly, because no one speaks to us, so we don’t know.
The run in maintains excitement and anxiety, I hope more return to the Brick to cheer on the boys. Hopefully we can see some return from injury, secure safety and all have some time to recover from the roller-coaster ride that has been Wigan Athletic version 25/26.
Up the resurgent yet inconsistent Tics!
Billy Haggerty:
Blackpool is always a good away trip with plenty of vocal support, and Saturday was no different. A decent 2,200 making the 37-mile journey albeit it via differing routes given the M6 northbound was shut near Preston for a few hours.
On the journey up I was surprised to see a tweet saying WAFC were up for sale, which I'll go into later. Onto the match, Callum Wright gave away a totally needless free-kick which we failed to defend, putting us on the back foot after a paltry four minutes. Make no mistake, Blackpool are a poor side, whose main Ian Evatt tactic was to lump it forward from anywhere with little to no play on the deck. Unfortunately, we at times tried to mimic their tactics, which failed miserably.
When we decided to play it on the floor, we were by far the better side. A well-taken goal by Owen Moxon was the least we deserved and, had luck been on our side, Joe Taylor's effort would have gone in off the post, giving us a deserved win rather than a share of the spoils. I also thought Wright could have done a little better with his effort later on.
Following on from that game, and there was more info coming out about our so called 'investment' announcement. It's not looking or sounding great, with rumours followed by counter rumours...Danson wants to sell, Danson just wants investment, Danson's got the stadium and so is longer interested, who wants to buy a club with no stadium, who wants a club with so many players out of contract...who, where, why, what, when?
The only real thing is that us fans are being kept in the dark and don't know what's going on or what's happening. Added to that, how on earth can the board employ a new manager who knows absolutely nothing about what the owners plans actually are? Truly, the blind leading the blind.
I feel for Gary Caldwell. He's come in, got the team looking like an actual football team, got the fans back on side, picked up a couple of decent wins, then BOOM! Another kick in the Latics nether regions. Only in little Wigan does stuff like this happen. Unnerving times ahead once again, so Mr Danson, Lucas D...if you read the 12th Man...please come clean, issue a statement, and don't gaslight the fans, we deserve better than that.
Now on to our midweek fixture against Plymouth and, with the uncertainty of the 'club for sale' debacle hanging over us, how would the the fans & team respond? Well, walking to the ground, it didn't feel like there was a game on. That was also mirrored in the stands, a very poor home crowd who were easily out sung by the 555 Plymouth fans who were far more vocal throughout the game, albeit they had more to sing about than us.
What a poor game. We didn't compete anywhere on the field, were second to every ball, and a few players seemed disinterested (no names, but you know who you are). Their first goal was a gift, but it just seemed like it was coming anyway with all the needless free-kicks we gave away on the edge of our box.
At 2-0, I thought the game was gone, as we don't always have two or even three goals in us to go on and win it, but when the BLATANT handball in their box isn't given, plus a red card, then we've absolutely no chance. That nailed-on penalty absolutely changes the game, but unfortunately it wasn't to be, and they go on to score a third.
What this defeat does, though, is to show that it wasn't all on Ryan Lowe. These players have to shoulder a good bit of the blame for our abject season. We are now back in the bottom four, and these players with the help of Caldwell and Perkins need to dig deep and fight for the shirt, the fans and their pride.
Starting on Saturday against Bradford, where it is 'bring a friend for free' game. Unfortunately, I think I'd have to pay a friend to watch if the same is on offer this Saturday. While not wanting to finish on a negative, hopefully we can muster up a win and some of the 'free friends' will become regulars after watching an emphatic win against Bradford!
Tony Moon:
So, the question is, who’s the king of hyperbole? Is it Trump, or is he himself trumped by the Latics fans? 'Worst I’ve seen'. 'As bad as anything we saw under Lowey'. 'Ashamed of every one of them'. 'As bad as anything under the last three managers'. 'Worst home performance in five years'.
Let’s face it, Tuesday was a really poor performance, but nevertheless, it was a game we could still have won. OH YES IT WAS! Of course, in the heat of a three-baht loss, people forget about the (few) decent things, and instead focus on (and rightly so) the poorer stuff. However, why the need to for overboard rubbish? Fair do to the manager though for putting the blame on himself (what a refreshing change). We just need to do better against Bratfut. Now, who’s going to kick Power and Humphries into the stand?!
Sean Livesey:
Latics returned to reality with a bump on Tuesday night after the relative positivity of the first few weeks under Gary Caldwell's leadership. Facing a resurgent Plymouth with an under-strength side was always going to be a difficult ask. To do so with fresh rumours circulating about the ownership of the club made a difficult task near impossible.
Let's look at the on the pitch side of it. Latics looked a shadow of the team they had for the last few weeks. A number of misplaced passes in the first few minutes allowed Plymouth to get a foot hold in the match.
Callum Mcmanaman - making a rare start - was screaming for an out ball that never came, while Sam Tickle - as dependable as they come - dropped an easy catch for Plymouth to go ahead.
Joe Taylor, who has been so important for the club over the last two months, once again could have scored. If that had gone in, who knows. But as the match went on, Latics struggles continued, Plymouth doubled their lead, but if we're being honest, it could have been a cricket score the way we were playing.
Half-time brought changes and a renewed bit of fight from Latics. The referee, who had been as inept as the rest of the league's officials in the first half, went on to another level as the most blatant handball since Maradona went completely unpunished. At that stage Latics were in the ascendency, who knows if a penalty and a goal back would have led to an equaliser but it certainly would have helped.
For both the linesman and the referee to see that and decide that it wasn't handball is one of the most ridiculous decisions I have ever seen in my 35 years of watching football. A matter of seconds later Plymouth went on to score their third of the match. Which summed up our evening and indeed the week.
Away from on the pitch matters, and Saturday saw the leak of a memorandum of sale for Wigan Athletic. With owner Mike Danson apparently deciding the time was right for the club to change hands. This was later published online by 'the Athletic', leading to horrible flashbacks from 2020 and 2023.
With the usual lack of communication from the owners, it's difficult to gauge what's actually happening here. Is Danson looking for additional investment to move Latics to another level? That's what the manager, who unfairly has been the only club official to comment on this, seems to think. It's also what the sale memorandum mentioned in terms of Danson remaining as a minority shareholder of 20 per cent.
That kind of makes sense. There's been no secret of the fact the Danson family weren't going to throw the astronomical sums of money at Latics that many others may expect, and some could say led us to this position in the first place.
If someone else with bottomless pockets wishes to throw their money at getting us up the leagues, with Danson as a safety measure if the proverbial did indeed hit the fan again, that would make sense. But all of this goes against the commitment we're frequently told about and the commitment that Caldwell has continually spoke about since his return.
Danson and his family have copped an unenviable amount of flack since taking over. Which is remarkable considering where we were and what we were in danger of becoming before he saved us. They have sunk a small fortune in just paying off the debts and keeping us in League One.
There wasn't a queue of wealthy individuals willing to throw their money away on a club that generates some of the lowest income in the EFL back in 2018, 2021 or indeed 2023 and there won't be this time. Unless you get lucky like a Wrexham or a Birmingham, you're always going to be looking over your shoulder for the next shyster. With Danson it may not have been exciting, but there was stability (of sorts) what comes next as ever is the concerning bit. The owners need to be honest with the supporters and with the staff.
If they've identified a way to progress under a new ownership model, then fine. But inform people. If they've decided they've had enough, well it flies in the face of everything we were told about the Wigan Sporting Group and everything else. Whatever it is, we need clarity and we need it soon.
