Gregor Rioch denies Wigan Athletic are 'Loan FC' - and what happened with Ben Ward, Ethan Erhahon, Rob Apter and Ben Woods
In the first of a two-part print exclusive, Gregor Rioch sat down with Wigan Today on Thursday afternoon to address a number of Wigan Athletic issues – including the all-important topic of recruitment.
Why have there been so many loan signings as opposed to permanent deals? Some fans have voiced fears this may be detrimental to long-term success...


When I first took this job almost three years ago, we were under a transfer embargo, meaning loan signings were key to anything we were doing. And we did do a fair few in that initial period. I think ideally you would want more permanent signings than loans, that's certainly the ideal, and I would be in agreement with that. Where we are at this moment in time - and certainly in this window - January is more geared to your short-term thinking, where the summer is more geared to your long-term thinking. When you are in the position we're in at the moment, it is quite difficult to encourage some players to come in on a permanent basis - especially when you're taking players from clubs with play-off aspirations - because they might be looking at getting promoted and moving up to Championship wages, and Championship status. Obviously if we do what we think we will do between now and the end of the season, and improve, then potentially we could turn those loans into permanent. There's no reason we couldn't look at, say, Owen Moxon and do that, or Callum Wright. Loans give you a really good chance to look at a player as well, so there's so many plusses to go with the obvious negatives of going that way. And you can turn loans into permanents at any point of the arrangement. Let's also look at the reality of bringing in loan players...we've had some really good loans in the last two or three years. Looking at season one, Martial Godo ended up being player of the season. Last season, DaleTaylor ended up being player of the season. So we have brought some pleasure to the group with loans...you've also got Luke Chambers, Charlie Kelman, Charlie Goode...all good loans, who were well recruited. One or two didn't hit the levels, but you will always get some that don't come off. Looking at Charlie Kelman, he's since gone on to better things at another club, but that shows the talent identification here. He didn't really play much, but we did try to bring him back to the club for a second season. But he'd already been for a previous loan spell at Leyton Orient under Richie Wellens, and Richie did a number on him...he said 'you didn't really play there, come to us and you will play', and that's something you can't control. But money is there for permanent deals that we identify that have value, and that remains the situation.
One of those ‘permanent deals with value’ would have been Benn Ward, who this week signed for Reading for a reported £500,000...how close was he to coming to Wigan?
We spoke with his representatives, we spoke with Accrington Stanley...obviously John Doolan (Accrington manager, former Latics player) is a good friend of this club, and he spoke very well of the young lad. We weren't in direct competition with anyone at the beginning, nobody else had made a bid when we were bidding, and we got to a level of what we thought was his value. They wanted more - which they have every right to want - and I think they did end up getting a bit more than what we ended up offering. But we decided at an early stage to pull back, and we do wish the lad well. He is a very talented boy, which is why we went for him in the first place. But we do a lot of data analysis, we can search every player...and we did a search on every defender that has moved from League Two to League One, what price they have gone for, and then how long it takes - in terms of games or months - that they have moved up to the Championship. Based on all that analysis, we'll decide we value that player at 'X', which is what we offered. From our point of view, we are very happy with Morgan Fox, who is our lead left-footed centre-back, and has 18 months remaining on his contract. To do a deal with Accrington, at the numbers they were talking about, we needed to guarantee Benn Ward was going to start. We had discussions about that, and we're quite happy with where we are on that score. Maybe he wouldn't have come here anyway, maybe he might have wanted more of a commitment in terms of starting games, rather than being part of a succession plan, as we've spoken about. Look, he might go on to become a multi-million pound player, and I certainly hope so. Because it will show that we're looking at the right sort of players.
Did you offer anywhere near the reported £500,000 that Accrington wanted?
In terms of the figures being bandied around...categorically no, we didn't make that offer to Accrington. We made three bids, very early on. We thought we were very respectful to Accrington, befitting of the really good relationship between the two clubs, in all aspects. We did it quickly, because we didn't want to upset the player, the manager or the club. Very quickly we were done, and we moved on. Since then, they had other offers from other clubs, and he ended up going to Reading. We wish him well.
You've mentioned before that, if you are going to spend the kind of money it would have taken to get Benn Ward, you would prefer to spend it further up the field...?
The thought process - and it is proven - is that if you're going to spend money on assets, as part of a 'player trading model' which gets bandied about, you're better off spending the bigger money higher up the pitch. Because the more goals they score, the more money they will end up going for. This is partly where we start to talk about 'sustainability', which a lot of people I don't think fully understand. So these players can help us grow, and help us improve, maybe climb into the division above. Or of they outgrow us, then we make good money on them.
Another potential transfer that didn’t happen was Ethan Erhahon, who went to Bolton Wanderers last summer. What exactly happened there?
Firstly, I think it's important to talk about the whole process of transfers, and this is a perfect chance to do that. I oversee player recruitment, as part of a number of other roles...including the Women's team, the Academy, sports science, data and analysis. So there's a big wide area of what I oversee regarding football matters. What I'm not is head of recruitment, or first-team coach. I just support them. So when it comes to player recruitment...it's the head of recruitment and his team that bring players to the fore, to the surface. They will sit down with the manager, or the head coach, and they'll make decisions on which players they want to go for. By the time it gets to me, they will already know whether it comes at a value we can afford, in terms of transfer fee and wages, and I get involved with the end bit...make sure there's due diligence, make sure there's nothing underhand, deal with the agents, etc. In summary, the recruitment team identifies, and the head coach makes the final decision. And at times, you get a last-minute situation, where everything is done, you've had the player in for a medical - which was the case in this situation with Ethan Erhahon. I knew there would be rival interest once we got a number out of Lincoln, because they were holding fire and trying to get more money. We ended up getting a deal done close to midnight, with the chief executive at Lincoln, finalising numbers, and he was booked in for a medical the following day. I then got a three-day exclusivity agreement on Ethan Erhahon - and I have it in writing - where Lincoln could not accept any other offer on the player for that period of time. I put that in because I knew, I had a feeling, that as soon as we got the number, other clubs would come in, because it was good value. He had his medical and then, travelling to the ground, I picked up his agent. But I'd already been tipped off that a couple of other clubs had come in and shown interest. When we got to the ground, the agent met with the player, and he asked to go into another room to discuss another option. And at that point, I knew he wasn't for us. He came out and said he would like to talk to another club, and I said that if he left the room now - and it was up to him - then the deal we were offering would no longer be on the table. As someone who looks after the greater good and betterment of this football club...if someone isn't prepared to commit to us, if they want to walk out of the room to talk to another club...if they don't want to wear our badge with pride, they can go. Yes, he went off to another football club but yes, we pulled the plug on our offer. There was no way back after that. I didn't want to wait three days, or even three months, to hear he wanted to go somewhere else. If you don't want to play for Wigan Athletic, you're not for me. Yes, you can say we missed out on that one. But you won’t find a sporting director at any football club that that hasn't happened to them at one point or another. It happens. And it's happened the other way, where we've managed to dive in and get players at the last minute, when they were pretty much committed to going elsewhere. That's football. In the end, I actually waived the three-day exclusivity, I said he could go, we had no interest in going back in for him. What would fans have wanted me to do...beg him to join our great football club? Or offer him more money? All I wanted to know if he really wanted to come here, and I had my answer.
Wigan Today was led to believe there hadn’t been a bid from Latics at the time...
It's tough, and I think you've got the toughest role in all this. A lot of it comes down to experience, and experiences...sometimes we make mistakes. Sometimes we have to hold our hands up, and look at how we relay information, to the local media and beyond. From my perspective, I will hold my hands up and say maybe I could have dealt with things a little bit different, a little bit better. The difficulty for you, and our relationship with you, is you can't always let on which players we are actively down the line with. Because there's an element of risk, that all of a sudden if you put it out there and commit to it...we know supporters ask you what's going on, you're then asking us what's going on, because we have that relationship. I can't always give a 'yes', because then it's out there from our local media, our trusted media, and the risk is two or three other clubs will possibly come in. That then becomes a problem, because where we might not have been fighting with other clubs for a player, suddenly we are up against it. And it is difficult...because there is also so much sh**e on social media, so many false rumours, about players, that you're constantly having to bat away. We weren't in for Rob Apter this week. We weren't in for Ben Woods...and I also read Ben Woods didn't come here because he doesn't like me! For the record, I've never even met Ben Woods. I've never even spoken to Ben Woods. We never even put a bid in to Accy - a club with whom we have a great relationship - so we wouldn't have had permission to speak to speak to Ben Woods. Had we watched him? Had we had reports on him? Did we like him? Yes, to all of the above. He's a Wigan lad, he's a Wigan fan, we knew all this. But at the time, we weren't looking for a midfielder, so he went to Peterborough. I didn't speak to him, because I don't usually speak to any player before they've done their medical. I'm only speaking to the agents and the clubs. Speaking to the player is down to Joe (Riley, chief scout) and the head coach. It only gets to me at a later stage, which might surprise a few, because I’m not sure many people are clear about what my role actually is. Hopefully this will help that understanding.