Wigan Athletic: The 12th Man - 'There’s no reason to put our heads down...'

Our panel of Latics experts run the rule over a real FA Cup scare against Hemel Hempstead ahead of another testing month ahead in League One – starting this weekend at Gary Caldwell’s Exeter City...

Matt Auffrey:

Paul Mullin reflects on his penalty miss against Hemel Hempsteadplaceholder image
Paul Mullin reflects on his penalty miss against Hemel Hempstead

It seems like ages have passed since we last experienced a comfortable victory. Forget about the nature of the competition (cup tie or league match) and if we played at home or not. Can you recall the last time we had an ‘easygoing’ match where we maintained control for the majority of the 90 minutes and did not suffer a major setback at any point?

We are coming up on eight weeks since our 3-0 victory over Doncaster at the Brick. Since then, our only victories have come against Port Vale - where we played the entire second half with 10 men - and against our most recent opponent, Hemel Hempstead.

Sam Tickle gives the thumbs upplaceholder image
Sam Tickle gives the thumbs up

Many common themes from the past two months’ matches reared their ugly head during last weekend’s FA Cup tie. We went up by a goal 25 minutes into the match, but the positive moment only seemed to have an inverse effect on our play, as we started to lose our composure and slowly invited the visitors back into the game.

By the time the hour mark had hit, our opponents had been knocking on the door of our goal for some time. Latics had just brought on their first pair of substitutes when a Hemel Hempstead ball played over the top of our defence forced the newly-introduced Matt Smith to make contact with their attacking player on the edge of our box.

The Hemel Hempstead player threw himself to the ground as if a shotgun shell went through his back. The referee not only blew his whistle for a foul, but awarded the visitors a penalty, while also sending Smith off for a 'last-man' foul.

The dubious decision will go down as another kick to the gut for a team that has already experienced numerous standing eight counts at the expense of some awful refereeing. Hemel Hempstead would convert from the spot, and continue to batter the Latics defence with a myriad of scoring chances over the remainder of the match.

Callum Wright celebrates his goalplaceholder image
Callum Wright celebrates his goal

A 74th-minute Paul Mullin penalty attempt that clipped the top of the crossbar before flying out of play only further confirmed the notion that a Latics victory was not meant to be. Yet, despite being bent to the utmost degree, our defence did not break, and we were given one final lifeline as we entered a penalty shoot-out after 120 minutes of play had passed.

One massive Sam Tickle save on the visitors’ second spot kick, coupled with five straight conversions by the hosts, allowed Latics to advance to the second round of the cup. But the match would go down as one of our least satisfying victories in a long time.

Hemel Hempstead’s mighty effort deserved a replay down south at the very least. There was no question they were the better team at the Brick that day. But as disappointing as large portions of last Saturday’s events turned out to be, what’s most important is that the lads did not fold.

Some egos certainly had to be bruised when the team was taken to the brink by a sixth-tier side. That didn’t stop us from putting our bodies on the line to produce some crucial blocks late in the match, while also summoning the composure to make five straight spot kicks to ultimately deliver victory.

Paul Mullin steps up to take his penaltyplaceholder image
Paul Mullin steps up to take his penalty

We’ve outplayed many teams over the first few months of the season, only to come away with less than we deserved from the final scoreline. We didn’t let those instances stop us from showing up in full force for the following match.

Now that we’re on the opposite side of that scenario, there’s no reason to put our heads down. A long trip to face a hungry Exeter side awaits us this weekend. We proved several weeks ago that we can go to Devon and produce a positive result when we secured a big point at Plymouth. It’s time to take our away performances to the next level. Let us hope that some of that lingering FA Cup magic sticks around for our next few league fixtures. We are certainly due for some extra form of help to get us across the finish line!

placeholder image
Read More
Ryan Lowe explains on-field huddle following Wigan Athletic's scare against Heme...

Martin Lally:

It’s now starting to get beyond the joke. I start this week by a direct question to the club: Do we ever challenge the competence of the decisions we have to endure week in week out by the officials? It’s starting to feel like even we have given up!

I appreciate the club reaches out to its fan base the best it can, but I do believe that any lay person would be appalled if they saw the standard of the decisions that are going against us week in week out! Is it really the same for all clubs? Let's examine…

We currently sit second in the League One 'Fair Play' table. We are not even a dirty team, but only Lincoln City sit above us. Now 22 yellow cards from 14 games doesn’t sound that bad, but our four direct red cards sit us top of that shop. Let’s be honest...the majority of those decisions have been questionable to say the least - and we have also been officiated by Mr Alan Young!

Will there be a game where we leave the ground in the near future finishing with the full complement? It’s hard to suggest we will. While the more cynical among us will fuel the fire of the argument that the EFL are simply against us, I simply believe the standard of officiating has again decreased this year.

Looking across the entirety of the football spectrum, it appears only a select handful seem to really understand the game, and the better level is certainly seen from the continent. Are we that self indulgent that our hopes and dreams of becoming football superstars means that the queue for the refereeing course is less busy than the half-time ones at the Brick? *Removes self from soap box for 16th time this season*

What can you say about Hemel Hempstead? That was simply one of the most gutsiest second-half performances I’ve seen for a long time and, if truth be told, they deserved to go through. But the sending-off was diabolical. Well done to Hemel for a gutsy performance - without Super Sam Tickle and two goal-line blocks we would be gone!

The other point of note at the minute is how at times in games a percentage of our players don’t look as fit as they could be. I seriously don’t know what’s going on there. Progression achieved though, banana skin avoided, and it’s onto a return for Scott Smith with his Barrow team in the next round.

This weekend we return to league action and it’s a big month with two homes and two aways, where we clash again with two ex-Wigan managers in Gary Caldwell and Leam Richardson. I watched Exeter recently against Plymouth, and on their day they are a right handful. But it’s a chance to stay in mid-table, and a good month would even put us on the coattails of the promotion chasing pack! In a season where it’s been ups and downs, I think by ‘Bommy Neet’ we would have probably all taken it.

Tony Moon:

Watching the news today (Monday), there’s a derailed train up near Shap. No mention, mind you, of the derailment down near Wigan Wallgate. What the hell has happened recently?

I can fully accept that the Doncaster game/result/performance initiated a little giddiness, and that’s always got to be tempered with a dose of reality. But oh my word, Saturday’s game seemed anything but real. Understandably - and quite rightly - the manager heeded the many calls to field a strong starting XI, but a dull and uninspiring first half barely hinted it was (near as damn it) our strongest available XI.

However, what a great performance in the second half and extra time...shame that performance wasn’t from Latics, mind you! But beggars can’t be choosers. I clapped Hemel Hempstead off at the end. Partly through appreciation, partly through embarrassment. I didn’t know what to make of the Phil Brown impression, but it can’t bode well...can it?

Sean Livesey:

All isn’t well at the Brick Community Stadium at the moment, and it shows. First off, let’s give full credit to Hemel Hempstead Town - The Tudors, as they’re affectionately known - who should be the ones in the second round of the FA Cup. Ryan Lowe admitted as much after Saturday’s game, and I think without penalties, Hemel would quite possibly have finished the job, so lacklustre was our performance.

Saturday followed a trend that’s been in motion since Bolton away back in September, where the only bright points have been a hard-earned win over Port Vale and a point apiece against Plymouth and then Mansfield.

Lowe went strong against the Tudors - far stronger than I expected - and when Callum Wright opened the scoring midway through the first half, many could have quite rightly expected Latics to go on to a comfortable win. But even in a first half that Lowe’s side dominated, Hemel Hempstead could have drawn level.

They picked up in the second half where they left off in the first, peppering Latics' goal and forcing the defence into conceding possession, and it was a surprise when Matt Smith was brought on - and an even bigger surprise when a penalty was conceded a minute later, resulting in his straight red.

It was a weak penalty to give away, but followed a path in a match where Latics struggled to assert themselves in any sort of positive manner. Callum McManaman again showed the heart that was missing when he was brought on, as he has done in various cup matches this season, but it can’t just be left to him to show what it means to wear that Tree and Crown. I’m sure the head coach will have referenced that in his post-match Phil Brown style huddle…

Latics can thank Jurgen Klopp’s sulking over his precious players playing too many matches for facing a penalty shoot-out as opposed to a Tuesday night trip to Hemel Hempstead, where I’m not sure - with our current away form - we would have reached the second round.

So we’re through but, as with the last two months, there is a lot of work to do. Next up it’s a trip to Exeter, and a certain Gary Caldwell and Josh Magennis. Exeter have had a difficult start to the season but sit only a point away from ourselves. They’ve also won five matches, where we’ve only won the four. But we’re a point ahead due to the higher number of draws. Three of those five wins have come at home, while we have yet to win away this season.

Perhaps it’s a good time to change that and get that first away win of the season on Saturday. But I worry as we begin to head into the depths of winter, if we don’t start picking up those wins, be they at the Brick or on the road.

If the Latics of August could return, I’m sure we’ll all be happy. I’m sure Lowe will be happy as well, because the collapse since Bolton has been both surprising and worrying in equal measure.

News you can trust since 1853
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice